Sometimes a pint is so good it unsettles what you think you know. This was one of those moments.
The Guinness I had last night at Boland’s was on point. It always is. I’ve been known to call it the best pour west of Dingle.
But sometimes it’s so good it messes with you a bit.
Makes you wonder if it’s actually the best pint you’ve ever had — even better than the best one in Ireland.
There’s often an emotional response when someone casually asks whether Guinness tastes different in the U.S. than it does in Ireland. Ask anyone from Ireland, or even someone who’s spent time there, and you’re unlikely to get a measured answer. What you’ll hear instead is an emphatic, almost offended, “Yes. Of course it is.”
And I’m usually one of those people.
I’ll argue it’s creamier. Thicker. Less bitter, yet somehow more complex. Fresher. I’ve made the case at bars and tables, mid-pint, waving a glass like evidence in a trial no one asked for.
But that pint at Boland’s gave me pause.
Not because it broke the rule. Ireland still holds it. Most days, it always will.
But because it reminded me that rules like that are built on something deeper than liquid.
If it were just the beer, we could recreate it anywhere. We haven’t.
People explain the difference a hundred ways — freshness, lines, gas mix, training, glassware. Others swear it has nothing to do with the beer at all, and everything to do with the room, the pace, the people, or the fact that you’re finally where the story began.
I’m not sure any of those explanations are wrong.
I’m also not sure any of them are complete.
Maybe that’s what a great pint does. It slows you down just enough to notice what’s really in the room.
The place.
The people.
The weight of the glass in your hand.
Every once in a while, one arrives that makes you question what you thought you knew — not about beer, but about why moments matter at all.
And when it does, you don’t rush to explain it.
You sit with it.
Settle in. THIS pint won’t drink itself.
– Mike
Comments ()